My Favorite Lobster Roll

Tucked away on the island of Georgetown, Maine, at Five Islands Wharf, this unassuming seafood shack serves what I consider the best lobster roll in the area. The lobsters are hauled from nearby waters and delivered straight to the shack—never held in tanks—which keeps the flavor bright and sweet. Their signature “big boy” lobster roll is a simple, perfect sandwich: generous chunks of tender lobster piled into a buttered, toasted bun with just a light touch of mayo to let the shellfish shine.

While the lobster roll is the star, the menu offers a range of excellent seafood options. The crab cakes are made with substantial lumps of crab, seasoned appropriately and pan-seared to a golden crust. The fried clams are crisp and fresh, a classic New England treat, and the grilled haddock is flaky and well seasoned for those who prefer a lighter preparation. Complementing these dishes are a few standout sauces: a bright homemade dill tartar and a cilantro-jalapeño mayonnaise that adds a gentle spicy, herbaceous lift. Pair any entrée with these sauces and the result is consistently satisfying.

The setting enhances the meal. Picnic tables at the end of the dock provide a relaxed, coastal dining experience where you can savor your food while watching the boats and tidal movement of Sheepscot Bay. The view is quintessential Maine—salt air, weathered pilings, and water stretching to the horizon—making it an ideal spot for both locals and visitors seeking authentic waterfront fare.

Service at the shack is friendly and straightforward. The staff focuses on quick, honest preparation rather than fussy presentation, which suits the laid-back atmosphere. Orders are typically prepared to go but can be enjoyed on-site at the dockside seating. Because the seafood is sourced locally and prepared simply, menu items can vary slightly depending on the catch of the day—another reason the experience feels fresh and connected to place.

Practical tips for visiting: arrive early in peak season to avoid a line, especially on sunny summer weekends. Bring a light jacket for breezy afternoons on the water. If you want to sample more than one specialty, consider sharing plates so you can try the lobster roll and a crab cake or a portion of fried clams. Don’t skip the sauces; the dill tartar and cilantro-jalapeño mayo are small touches that elevate the dishes.

Overall, Five Islands Wharf offers an authentic Maine seafood experience: fresh, simply prepared lobster and other seafood, served in a scenic, relaxed setting. Whether you come specifically for the famed “big boy” lobster roll or for a sampling of their other seafood specialties, you’re likely to leave satisfied and planning a return visit.

Contact

1447 Five Islands Rd
Georgetown, ME 04548
207.371.2990
fiveislandslobster.com